83% of America’s counties voted for Trump in the 2020 election but these counties account for only 29% of America’s GDP. Why aren’t this lesser off rural/exurban population voting for the party that theoretically are most aligned with their interests i.e. the Democratic Socialists? The answer might lie with Karl Marx who saw this population as “rural idiots” representing “barbarism within civilisation”. For Marx only the urban working class could bring about societal transformation. Every successful Communist revolution had to unlearn this bias of Marx. Looking at the American political situation today we see two Americas: a rural/exurban ocean and a densely populated urban and suburban archipelago. And like Marx rather than his successful revolutionary followers, the Far Left of today dismiss these ruralites as Conservative Reactionaries rather than the most readily mobilisable support.