What Would Be the Fundamental Principles of an “Anarchy First” Movement?

By John Wilkes Czolgosz

Anarchy is a diverse and complex ideology with varying interpretations and principles. The principles of an anarchist movement can differ depending on specific schools of thought or individual perspectives. However, some fundamental principles commonly associated with anarchism include:

  1. Opposition to Hierarchical Authority: Anarchists generally reject hierarchical structures and advocate for the abolition of systems that concentrate power and authority, such as the state, capitalism, and oppressive social institutions. They aim to replace hierarchical systems with non-coercive, voluntary, and decentralized forms of organization.
  2. Individual Liberty: Anarchists emphasize the importance of individual freedom and autonomy. They argue for the elimination of oppressive systems that restrict individual liberties, including state control, surveillance, and authoritarianism. Anarchy promotes the belief that individuals should have the freedom to make decisions and live their lives without interference, as long as it does not infringe upon the equal freedom of others.
  3. Direct Action: Anarchists advocate for direct action as a means to effect change. This can include nonviolent civil disobedience, grassroots organizing, mutual aid, and community self-governance. Direct action is seen as a way to challenge oppressive structures and create alternative systems that align with anarchist principles.
  4. Voluntary Cooperation and Mutual Aid: Anarchy promotes voluntary cooperation and mutual aid as alternatives to hierarchical structures. Anarchists believe that individuals can come together voluntarily to organize and meet their needs without the need for external authorities. Mutual aid emphasizes solidarity, empathy, and support within communities to address social and economic challenges.
  5. Horizontalism and Decentralization: Anarchists advocate for horizontal decision-making processes and decentralized forms of governance. This means power and decision-making are distributed among individuals or small groups rather than being concentrated in a central authority. Consensus-based decision-making, participatory democracy, and self-governance are often promoted as principles for organizing society.
  6. Ecological Harmony: Many anarchists emphasize the importance of ecological sustainability and environmental stewardship. They argue that hierarchical systems, such as capitalism, exploit natural resources and contribute to ecological destruction. Anarchist principles aim to create a society that prioritizes ecological harmony and sustainable practices.

It is important to note that the interpretations and applications of these principles can vary among different anarchist thinkers and movements. Anarchy as a philosophy and political ideology is diverse and can encompass a range of perspectives and strategies for social change. It is likewise important to consider how an “Anarchy First” movement reconcile the differences between the various types of anarchism, including but not limited to anarcho-capitalism, anarcho-fascism, anarcho-monarchism, anarcho-conservatism, anarcho-masculinism, national-anarchism, individualist-anarchist, Georgist anarchism, Christian anarchism, Buddhist anarchism, Islamic anarchism, Jewish anarchism, anarcho-communism, anarcho-syndicalism, collectivist-anarchism, anarcho-primitivism, black anarchism, anarcha-feminism, queer anarchism, Green anarchism, and anarcho-transhumanism?

Reconciling the differences between the various types of anarchism within an “anarchy first” movement would be a complex and challenging endeavor. Anarchy, as a broad ideology, encompasses diverse and sometimes conflicting perspectives on how society should be organized and the means to achieve a stateless and non-hierarchical society. However, there are a few possible approaches that could be taken:

  1. Focus on Common Ground: An “anarchy first” movement could emphasize the shared principles and values among different anarchist traditions, such as opposition to hierarchical authority, individual liberty, and voluntary cooperation. By highlighting these commonalities, it may be possible to find areas of collaboration and build solidarity across different anarchist perspectives.
  2. Respect for Pluralism and Diversity: Acknowledging and respecting the diversity within anarchism is essential. An “anarchy first” movement could strive to create an inclusive and open environment that encourages dialogue, understanding, and mutual respect among different anarchist tendencies. This would require recognizing that there will always be a range of perspectives within the anarchist movement and that no single viewpoint should dominate or exclude others.
  3. Consensus-Building and Democratic Processes: Anarchist principles often emphasize decentralized decision-making and direct democracy. An “anarchy first” movement could adopt these principles by employing consensus-building processes that allow for open discussion, active participation, and collective decision-making. This approach would aim to ensure that decisions and actions are made through inclusive and participatory processes that respect the voices of all involved.
  4. Pragmatic Coalition-Building: An “anarchy first” movement could seek to form coalitions and alliances based on shared goals and objectives. This approach would involve identifying areas of common interest and working together on specific issues or campaigns while recognizing and respecting the differences in long-term visions or strategies. By focusing on practical goals and shared principles, cooperation among diverse anarchist tendencies becomes possible.

It is important to note that some of the ideologies  mentioned, such as anarcho-fascism or anarcho-monarchism, may not align with the fundamental principles of anarchism, such as opposition to hierarchical authority. These ideologies are often considered contradictory to the core principles of anarchy. However, within a diverse movement, open dialogue and critical engagement with differing perspectives can help clarify and refine the principles and goals of an “anarchy first” movement.

Therefore, it is necessary to determine how there can be collaboration between forms of anarchism that are primarily oriented toward anti-statism and those which are primarily oriented to opposition to hierarchical authority.

Collaboration between forms of anarchism primarily oriented toward anti-statism and those primarily oriented to opposition to hierarchical authority can be challenging due to their different focuses and approaches. However, there are potential avenues for collaboration that can bridge these perspectives:

  1. Common Objectives: Despite their different orientations, many forms of anarchism share common objectives such as individual liberty, voluntary cooperation, and opposition to oppressive systems. Identifying and focusing on these shared goals can create a foundation for collaboration. For example, both anti-statist and opposition-to-hierarchy anarchists may seek to challenge oppressive institutions or promote decentralized decision-making processes.
  2. Intersectional Analysis: Adopting an intersectional approach can help identify the ways in which different systems of oppression intersect and reinforce each other. Recognizing that oppressive structures are interconnected and understanding their interplay can create opportunities for collaboration. By acknowledging the ways in which hierarchical authority and the state can perpetuate various forms of oppression, different forms of anarchism can find common ground in opposing these systems collectively.
  3. Tactical Alliances: Collaboration can occur on specific issues or campaigns where the objectives align. Tactical alliances allow different anarchist tendencies to come together around shared causes, even if their long-term visions may differ. This approach recognizes that diverse perspectives can contribute different strengths and strategies to collective action. By focusing on specific goals, such as fighting against a specific oppressive policy or supporting a particular social movement, different forms of anarchism can find practical ways to collaborate.
  4. Dialogue and Mutual Learning: Engaging in open dialogue and mutual learning is crucial for fostering collaboration. Anarchists with different orientations can engage in respectful conversations, sharing their perspectives, experiences, and analysis. This exchange can lead to a deeper understanding of each other’s viewpoints and potentially identify areas of common ground or new possibilities for collaboration.
  5. Strategic Coalition-Building: Collaboration can also occur through strategic coalition-building. This involves forming alliances or networks that bring together diverse anarchist tendencies and other social movements or communities. By recognizing the collective power in unity, diverse anarchist groups can contribute their unique strengths and perspectives to broader movements for social change.

While collaboration between different orientations within anarchism may require negotiation, compromise, and ongoing dialogue, it is possible to find points of convergence and work together on common goals. The key lies in recognizing shared values, focusing on practical objectives, and maintaining a commitment to open and respectful communication.

Leave a Reply