History and Historiography

How the United States Constitution Created a Totalitarian America

While I agree with the general argument of this article (“The Anti-Federalists were right!”), I would disagree the USA is totalitarian in its present form. The DPRK is currently the only state organized on a classically totalitarian 20th-century model. About a third of the world’s countries remain traditional authoritarian states. The other two-thirds could be considered liberal or semi-liberal states that exhibit authoritarian characteristics to varying degrees.
I break with mainstream political theorists’ commonly held view that “democracies” cannot be “authoritarian.” Most democratic regimes are a hybrid of libertarian and authoritarian tendencies. I would agree with some of the criticisms of “democracy” voiced by various classical, medieval, classical liberal, socialist, anarchist, and libertarian thinkers. I would characterize modern “democracy” as a hybrid of plutocratic, statist, imperialist, democratic, libertarian, and ochlocratic tendencies. Any country larger than Lichtenstein will devolve into tyranny or chaos eventually.

Calvin P. Kennedy Jr.

Calvin P. Kennedy Jr. Feb 20, 2023

How the United States Constitution Created a Totalitarian America

Photo by John Bakator on Unsplash

For centuries, the United States Constitution has served as North America’s decree. It is the legal order that establishes the right to power for the federal government of the United States of America. The founding fathers, some of America’s greatest men, drafted the United States Constitution in order to create a government with sufficient power to protect America and its citizens. They also drafted it to create a government that did not have so much power that it could violate humanity’s fundamental rights, but the primary goal was to establish a workable level of national security to mitigate the power of external threats while also protecting citizens from the negative consequences of big government.

Unfortunately, the United States Constitution has accomplished the polar opposite of what it was intended to accomplish. America has been a totalitarian state since the founding of the constitution; there is no such thing as a constitutionally protected right when the constitution gives the federal government the sole authority to define what a right is and isn’t; this means that a law and a right can be relegated to any moral standard seen as fit by those in political and economic power. The United States Constitution has allowed the government to expand to the point where it severely oppresses humanity by enacting a slew of ostensible laws disguised as solutions to improve the lives of American citizens. The constitution is also a document that finalizes the ground rules for democracy, which means that through political power, the minority is subjugated to the majority, which also means that the constitution inherently establishes a foundation for discrimination, favoritism, widespread discontent, and political and social division among citizens.

It should not be forgotten that even long after the United States Constitution was ratified, many injustices were allowed to take place because of the constitutional powers granted to the government. It should also be remembered that slaves were created based on skin color even after the United States Constitution was ratified. Restrooms, water fountains, and schools were colored-only or white-only. There were sundown towns, sexist workplace policies against women, anti-voting laws against non-white minorities, anti-union laws to protect harmful corporations from working voices, laws that denied housing based on race, laws that allowed Asians to be placed in camps, and laws that legally deported innocent Irish people simply because they were Irish. The United States Constitution failed to protect Americans and their right to free speech when the government enacted the Sedition Act of 1918 and the Espionage Act of 1917, resulting in mass censorship and incarceration of Americans. These conditions and punishments were only permitted because the constitution granted the government the authority to enact such oppressive laws. It is critical to remember that simply because something is protected by systemic legality does not imply that it is morally correct or good.

READ MORE

Categories: History and Historiography

Tagged as:

2 replies »

  1. Honestly I think the USA is the most totalitarian state in history, and that is because of the depth and breadth of its economic coercion and brainwashing. The Sovs, ChiComs and Nazis may have shot a larger proportion of their own people, but current US incarceration rates compare to concentration camps in earlier eras, and libertarians would want to argue that drug laws are political persecution.
    The USA is not quite a police state (depending on where you live, ie not New Jersey) but it is a totalitarian state whose tentacles of coercion based manipulation tactics draw more extensively upon the resources, and infiltrate the society of, the world than any empire in history. States cannot ever reach any kind of equilibrium with the economy and population, and more sophisticated extortion rackets are ultimately worse.
    For example, could the empire of Nebuchadnezzar be a threat to Texas? Nebuchadnezzar would be drone bombed in seconds. Only the parasite, octopus state can effectively sap the life of industrial society, and the damage it does – objectively, and by counterfactual by plausible conjecture – is so extreme that it would have literally destroyed the human species is it had somehow been possible.
    No thanks to the state, humans have great technical and numerical advantages now. But if the state, as it exists, had existed in the past, it would have been a great extinction event.
    The most trivial states today are more dangerous than volcanos and hurricanes in human history. If they’re even suspected of being irresponsible or illegitimate, their dissolution follows. Anyone who would not abolish uncontrolled hurricanes is ipso facto someone who’s opinion doesn’t matter.

Leave a Reply