History and Historiography

Yes, the 1970s and 1980s Were the Best Time To Grow Up

No social media, no Internet and grownups minding their own business is a recipe for success

Nostalgia for the 1970s and 1980s childhood is all over Instagram, and I’m here to tell you that it’s just as great as advertised.

This is not to say that it was perfect—of course, it wasn’t.1 There’s no such thing as perfect, but there are much better ways to live than the way we do today.

I have Gen X friends who grew up in working or middle-class families in small towns and big cities and who are of different races and different religions. We all have essentially the same memories of that period when it comes to lifestyle: riding our bikes everywhere, drinking out of garden hoses, playing kick the can, and listening to Casey Kasem countdowns with our cassette players at the ready so we could record our favorite songs.

Perhaps most importantly, we lived mostly out of sight of our parents except when we were called home for meals.

Cynics will say that everybody remembers their childhood as idyllic, but I can tell you that my parents did not. Based on the Millennial and Gen Z writers I read, they believe—correctly, in my opinion—that they were dealt a pretty bad hand in terms of the time period in which they were raised.

My parents felt they had very oppressive childhoods with controlling parents and lots of rules. They wanted to be different kinds of parents, and you could argue that the parents of Gen X kids engaged in a kind of over-correction. But I would take that kind of hands-off parenting over the alternative. If I had had my parents tracking me on an app, which is commonplace for Gen Z kids, I would’ve felt trapped, controlled, and extremely anxious.

I have intense nostalgia for my childhood and teen years, even though I had a fairly turbulent home life. My parents divorced when I was five, which was very unusual for the time, at least where I lived. Additionally, I had a lot of conflict with them, and like many parents of that era, they weren’t great at healthily handling conflict.

Still, I remember my childhood and teen years as a really happy time.

I think it speaks to how radically different life was during those years as compared to today, mostly because it pre-dated the technology that has taken over our lives. I haven’t always felt such strong nostalgia, and I suspect it is more intense now because life today feels so much harder and more complicated for everyone, including children and teenagers who suffer from historic levels of anxiety and depression.

It seems correct to blame social media and the Internet for much of the unhappiness that Millennials and Gen Z have experienced. Their brains were inundated with too much stimulation and information before they were fully developed, and that’s bad enough. But it’s not just that they spent (and continue to spend) their time on apps comparing themselves to other people and jacking up their nervous systems with nonstop bad news from around the world.

It’s also what they were not doing as children.

In hindsight, I can see how spending so much time outside (and not using electronics) was important in regulating my nervous system as a child. My father lived on three acres of land, which meant my brother and I were pushed out of the house right after breakfast. We didn’t return until it was time for lunch, and then we went back out until dinner. In the winter, this usually meant sledding for hours on end. At my mother’s house, we were in a neighborhood, which meant going outside and riding our bikes or playing games with other kids.

Younger generations might wonder what I mean when I say we were pushed out of the house. I mean, we were literally told to get out of the house. “I don’t want to see your face again” was a familiar refrain if we took too long to depart. Our parents did not feel any need to entertain us or play with us. We were expected to entertain ourselves and to basically leave them alone.

Most of my friends were from working-class or middle-class families and their mothers didn’t have jobs outside the home. It never occurred to the mothers to play with us or provide us with entertainment. They were busy taking care of the laundry or cooking meals. When they weren’t, we were expected to stay out of their way while they congregated or watched soap operas.

Since the idea of “play dates” hadn’t been invented, we were forced to play whith whomever was around, whether a sibling or a neighborhood kid we disliked. This mixture of being outside and playing with other children without adult supervision—including when conflicts arose—was important for our development.

Not having social media or the Internet was a huge blessing. This doesn’t distinguish Gen X from preceding generations, but it does from succeeding generations. There were no personal computers or cell phones. People (parents) couldn’t track you down wherever you were. I was in high school when we got an answering machine, and we were one of the first families to have one.

No television stations were dedicated to entertaining us, and when a movie targeted at teens came out—Sixteen Candles, St. Elmo’s Fire, the Breakfast Club—it was a big event.

We were often bored, and nobody cared. We just accepted it as a normal part of life.

Baby boomers experienced a lot of what I’ve outlined about my childhood, but they didn’t have as much freedom as Gen X kids. They also came of age during a period with a lot of societal upheaval and the Vietnam War.

One final point: Millennials and Gen Zers will say they are more anxious and depressed than other generations because of climate change. They believe no other generation lived with the specter of total annihilation hanging over them. This is incorrect.

Multiple generations, including Gen X, lived in fear of a nuclear holocaust. What’s different is that while we were aware of the threat, we weren’t constantly consuming information about it on social media because social media didn’t exist. The news was delivered once a day in the evening for a half hour, not every second of the day. We also weren’t chronically emotionally dysregulated as most people (children and adults) are today, so we could metabolize this fear without feeling incapacitated by it.

What younger generations deal with that we didn’t is active shooter drills. Such a thing was unthinkable. I never spent one minute worrying about being shot at school—or anywhere. I can’t imagine what that does to a child’s development.

There is obviously no going back, and there is plenty that is better about today’s world, but I’m paying attention to my nostalgia to see where I can recreate some of that sense of freedom from constant stimulation, more time outdoors and yes, even learning to welcome boredom as a good and positive part of life.

1

Sexism, racism, ableism and homophobia were much worse during this time. They are obviously still problems—we still have a long way to go.

 

Changing The Channel with Kirsten Powers

Recommend Changing The Channel with Kirsten Powers to your readers

New York Times bestselling author Kirsten Powers offers fresh thinking about how we can make big changes in our lives, communities and country.

Leave a Reply