The Politics of Contradiction: When the Far Right Embraces Israel

The scene was surreal: Elon Musk, one of the world’s richest men, standing at a podium at an AFD rally in Germany, defending a party frequently accused of neo-Nazi sympathies while simultaneously proclaiming his support for Israel. Yet in today’s political landscape, this contradiction barely raises eyebrows.

We’re witnessing a remarkable shift in global politics, where far-right movements have become some of Israel’s most vocal supporters. It’s a partnership that would seem impossible at first glance, yet it’s happening in plain sight. From American evangelicals to European nationalists, groups that have historically harbored antisemitic views are now wrapping themselves in the Israeli flag.

Share

The roots of this paradox run deep. Theodore Herzl, Zionism’s founding father, made a calculated decision in 1895 when he declared that “antisemites will become our most dependable friends.” His logic was cold but clear: those who opposed Jewish integration in Europe would support the creation of a Jewish state elsewhere. Today, that same logic drives an unholy alliance between Israel and the far right.

Take the American evangelical movement. Pastor John Hagee, leader of Christians United for Israel, once claimed that “God sent Adolf Hitler to help Jews reach the Promised Land.” Despite such inflammatory rhetoric, his organization continues to pour millions into Israel annually. The Israeli government, far from rejecting this support, embraces it. When the March for Israel needed speakers after October 7th, Hagee was welcomed with open arms.

This pattern repeats across the globe. In Romania, Israel’s ambassador met with the far-right AUR party – direct descendants of the fascist Iron Guard that once slaughtered Jews in Bucharest’s streets. In Germany, the AFD party finds common cause with Israeli nationalism while working to minimize Nazi atrocities. These aren’t isolated incidents but part of a strategic alignment.

Richard Spencer, a leading figure in America’s alt-right movement, laid bare this connection in 2017 when he branded himself a “White Zionist.” Speaking to Israeli television, he drew explicit parallels: “As an Israeli citizen who has a sense of nationhood and peoplehood, you should respect someone like me who has analogous feelings about whites.” The comparison was shocking, but the logic was uncomfortably clear.

Even organizations meant to combat antisemitism have been caught in this web. The Anti-Defamation League, which compares Palestinian symbols to Nazi imagery, found itself defending Musk’s controversial gestures. The message is clear: support for Israel trumps concerns about antisemitism.

This alliance isn’t just about political convenience. For many on the far right, Israel represents a model: a nation that openly prioritizes one ethnic group’s interests while maintaining democratic pretenses. They see in Israel’s policies a blueprint for their own nationalist aspirations.

The implications of this alliance extend far beyond the Middle East. As far-right movements gain strength globally, their embrace of Israel provides them with a shield against accusations of bigotry while legitimizing their broader nationalist agenda. It’s a dynamic that would have been unthinkable a generation ago, yet here we are.

In this new political landscape, old categories of left and right, friend and foe, have become hopelessly blurred. The only constant is the pursuit of power, and the willingness to embrace contradiction in its service. As we grapple with rising nationalism worldwide, understanding these alliances becomes crucial. They reveal not just the complexity of modern politics, but the moral compromises we make in its name.