The following is an updated version of an older post from my previous blog.
Have you ever wondered why people from ‘older’ cultures such Chinese, Indian, Greek, Italian often seem more dishonest than those from others such as German, Swedish, Russian- at least on a superficial level. Some might want to believe that this difference in general attitudes and behavior is somehow linked to race or genes. I have proposed a very different theory in a couple of posts on my old blog-
“The general level of personal honesty in any group of people is inversely proportional to the amount of time spent by their ancestors under highly hierarchical states, of any size, that were predominantly based on violent coercion while providing little, or no, benefit to its subjects.”
To understand what I am getting at, we have first talk about how fiefdoms, city-states, kingdoms, empires etc were governed and for whose benefit. The brief version is that almost every such entity prior to the 1860s-1870s was an extortion racket run almost exclusively for the benefit of those in power, at the expense of everyone else. That is why the grandest archeological remains of most kingdoms and empires largely consist of palaces, villas, castles, walls and other proxies for systems based on extortion rather than large public civil engineering projects which would benefit the majority. This is also why the construction of large public works by Roman Empire and some Chinese dynasties are historic anomalies. The majority of governments throughout human history were content with extorting and stealing from their subjects so that a few could live in great personal luxury without proving any real benefit to those who they governed- and this pattern began with the first “civilizations”.
The first “civilizations” came into being in certain fertile regions of the world such as Middle-East, Egypt, India, Iran, China, Mediterranean Coast and Mesoamerica. They can be distinguished from previous proto-civilizations because the later were far less hierarchical and centralized. For the vast majority of recorded human history, more “civilization” equals more exploitation of masses by a group of small self-anointed elites and their flunkies. Notably, this occurred for far longer and more intensively in certain parts of the world compared to others. For example- other than the brief expansion and subsequent fall (50 BC- 350AD) of Roman Empire in North-Western Europe which gave rise to a few medium-sized cities and some degree of centralized governance, the first organic large kingdoms and cities in that region did not form until the 11-12th century AD. Even then, the level and extent of administrative centralization and urbanization in that region did not reach levels seen along the Mediterranean coast until the 14th-15th century AD. In other words, people from older civilizations developed their cultural mores under pressures and in environments that were quite different from those in more recent ones.
So what is the nature of process which creates certain cultural mores that are far more common in older “civilizations” than others? For most of their history as a species, humans were hunter-gatherers who lived in fairly non-hierarchical societies. Even after agriculture came onto the scene, proto-societies and proto-kingdoms largely retained many of the previous traditions- as long as the degree of administrative centralization remained low. To be more specific, these societies had a very shallow social hierarchy and those at the top of that hierarchy were in the same boat as their underlings. Coupled with the inability to efficiently accumulate and transmit large amounts of wealth and power over multiple generations, these societies were fairly free of people who were especially dishonest. Then the advent of large-scale agriculture and administrative centralization, necessary for the functioning of larger kingdoms, occurred in certain parts of the world. While this new mode of food production and social organization had advantages under a certain set of conditions- it had many other unanticipated negative effects such as a large increase in the size of some settlements- creating the first cities. Previously, functional human groups and societies were rarely much larger than a few thousand. However, the combination of intensive agriculture, urbanization and administrative centralization allowed those numbers to routinely reach into the tens to hundreds of thousands and even millions. The leadership class of such large was increasingly able to isolate themselves from their subjects and exploit them in ways that were hitherto not possible. The need to efficiently exploit such groups also necessitated the development of needlessly complex and tall hierarchies with plenty of sociopath-friendly laws and regulations.

Now ask yourself- what sort of person would gain power and resources in any highly hierarchical society with many laws and regulations? The answer is obvious, but seldom discussed in polite society. Such systems will always select for and reward people with sociopathic tendencies. However, the concentration of sociopaths near the lever of power in any society will always have two downstream effects.
1. Survival under such a regime requires the majority to also adopt behaviors and attitudes similar to their sociopathic elites. Therefore such societies inevitably become cesspits of fake politeness, backstabbing, treachery and generalized dishonesty.
2. If we assume that sociopathic tendencies are partly inherited- it is possible that older civilizations might have a higher percentage of sociopaths in their populations than those from younger civilizations.
Now readers might wonder- Is it possible to partially reverse high levels of ambient dishonesty and dysfunction in such cultures? The answer is yes- with one caveat. The process of systematically destroying old socio-economic systems along with its elites is messy and requires taking down almost all of its major institutions along with their members- which requires getting rid of about 5-10% of the population. Only a fairly deep social reset, be it through some combination of natural disasters, war, or internal collapse can reliably make a society less sociopathic and dysfunctional. During the past century, only a combination of large-scale revolutions, brutal civil wars and large-scale purges has achieved that end. Examples of semi-successful transformations include the Russian revolution + ensuing civil war + purges + WW2 and its aftermath or the Chinese civil war (Part 1) + partial Japanese occupation + civil war (part 2) + aftermath of WW2 and Cultural Revolution. In summary, there is no easy and nice way to fix dysfunctional societies and civilizations.
What do you think? Comments?
Categories: Uncategorized

















