| Excitement abounds around the possible, perhaps likely, upcoming tripartite meeting in Shenzen, China among Presidents Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, and Donald Trump at the November 18-19 meeting of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Some are calling it Yalta 2.0. We’d rather think of it as Reykjavik 2.0., while also welcoming some of the broader diplomatic breakthroughs and global reordering achieved at Yalta almost 82 years ago.
Dmitry Trenin, former longtime director of the Carnegie Moscow Center and current President of the Russian International Affairs Council, wrote encouragingly, “The US president has mentioned that an unprecedented trilateral meeting… would make sense if it were focused on denuclearization.” Trenin wrote this in Al Jazeera in the context of explaining why Russia could play a helpful role in negotiating a new nuclear agreement between its Iranian ally and the United States. While anything that might help end the dangerous, destructive, and potentially apocalyptic conflagration in Southwest Asia would be more than welcome, we think the leaders can and should reach even higher. Why not rekindle the spirit of the 1986 meeting between Presidents Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev, at which they came within a hairsbreadth, arguably one word, of eliminating not only all ballistic missiles as Reagan originally proposed but all nuclear weapons as Gorbachev countered. Reagan replied, “Yes, all” and Secretary of State George Shultz agreed. “Let’s do it,” he said. The chance to achieve the most extraordinary diplomatic breakthrough in history slipped through Reagan’s grasp when he insisted on unlimited testing of his Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI) fantasy rather than limiting SDI to the laboratory for ten years. The world’s hopes were dashed and we have not come even close ever since.
Sure, we’re up against obstacles and the odds against this are long. Donald Trump has responded to the midterm shellacking by appointing Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff – in effect giving the middle finger to those who didn’t support the Republicans, which is not a hopeful sign. Putin knows that much of Russian power comes not from its economic prowess or its conventional military but from possessing the largest nuclear arsenal in the world. And Xi Jinping has made it clear that China won’t engage in arms control talks until it achieves rough nuclear parity with the U.S. and Russia; it has been rapidly increasing the size of its arsenal as a result. |