Uncategorized

National-Anarchism and ‘Non-coercive Coercion’

ALAN Watts once spoke of a “liberty to love and to fear, to fight and to yield, to resist and to accept and – yes – to be free and to be compelled, for freedom is not absolutely free unless it is also free to be bound!”

Whilst this might sound like a gross contradiction in terms, it actually represents the resolution of two opposites and the fact that we National-Anarchists wish to establish autonomous communities that are centred around a multitude of different ideas is a useful way to account for the apparent contradiction that Watts mentions.

One thing that hasn’t been discussed in relation to National-Anarchism in the past, is the possible nature of those settlements which may be established on the basis of what I would describe as ‘non-coercive coercion’. Although we are completely adamant that our communities should be genuinely Anarchist in nature, not to mention entirely voluntary, what is one to make of those who may wish to form communities that are centred on forms of coercive ‘play’?

I often refer to theme-based communities in which something like horror or science-fiction acts as the central or unifying idea of the community itself, but this should not imply that people who like to dress up as Count Dracula or Darth Vadar are not serious about their Anarchist principles. However, we also need to consider what Alan Watts says about retaining the freedom to be compelled into doing something by others.

Whilst few of us would relish being carried off by Frankenstein’s monster, or face being exterminated by an Anarchist dalek, we cannot rule out the fact that some people like to perform roles that are often filed under the heading ‘master and servant’. The obvious example, of course, is that of sexuality and those who like to indulge in such fantasies never lose sight of the fact that, ultimately, the ‘game’ can come to an end whenever they choose. If this kind of understanding is applied to what I described above as ‘non-coercive coercion,’ therefore, the potential for National-Anarchist communities to assume an even more diverse number of forms is heightened considerably.

As Watts explained, there is no real freedom without having the freedom to yield and as long as that is consensual it does not become a threat to the more fundamental principles of Anarchy. After all, who has the right to inform a group of men who enjoy living in an Amazonian harem that they are labouring under the sharpened high heels of an oppressive matriarchy when they are perfectly happy to do so?

Categories: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply