Uncategorized

‘A Repugnant Facet of American Life’

Sponsored by Penguin Press

“Mention of the death penalty can provoke an instinctual recoil,” writes Piper French in the Review’s December 3 issue. “Faced with such a repugnant facet of American life, most people find it easier to look away.” The journalist Pamela Colloff, on the other hand, “has spent many years meticulously documenting structural problems with the criminal legal system through individual cases, working especially on wrongful convictions and the death penalty.” Colloff’s latest book, French writes, takes the case of Jim Dailey—an innocent man put on death row in Florida by the false testimony of the notorious jailhouse informant Paul Skalnik, “a habitual criminal who will say anything if he stands to gain”—as an opportunity to examine the kinds of violence and corruption that sustain both capital punishment and the crimes it’s supposed to prevent.

Below, alongside French’s article, are five essays from our archives about America’s death penalty.

Piper French
The Executioner’s Song

Pamela Colloff’s Catch the Devil is as much the tale of a notorious jailhouse informant who put an innocent man on death row as it is the story of the officials and institutions that encouraged his lies.

Jack Hanson
Last Rites

Executions prevent any possibility that the condemned might someday reconcile with the world, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church maintains that they are “an attack on the inviolability and dignity of the person.” So why do powerful American Catholics still support the practice?

—October 20, 2024

Bernard E. Harcourt
The Barbarism of Alabama’s Botched Execution

The governor should place a moratorium on lethal injection and order an immediate full inquiry by an independent commission into the bungled execution of Doyle Hamm.

—March 13, 2018

Lorrie Moore
Werner Herzog on Death Row

“Herzog is interested in American violence reflected even in the names of Texas towns—‘Cut and Shoot’ is one—as well as the way that death and mayhem lying literally next door are moved on from, whereas superstition—rainbows and departed spirits—is not.

—November 10, 2011

John Paul Stevens
On the Death Penalty

“Two years ago, quoting from an earlier opinion written by Justice White, I wrote that the death penalty represents ‘the pointless and needless extinction of life with only marginal contributions to any discernible social or public purposes.’”

—December 23, 2010

David Cole
Hope and Betrayal on Death Row

Being a death-row lawyer is hard work. Underpaid and overburdened, death-row attorneys are always racing against time; nothing concentrates the mind like an execution date. The stakes are literally life or death in every case, making it virtually impossible to leave the job behind at the office—much less to take a vacation. The clients are usually guilty of heinous murders, and almost always come from brutally depressed and violent backgrounds.

—November 25, 2010

Special Offer
Subscribe for just $1 an issue and receive a FREE 2027 calendar

Get the deal

Politics   Literature   Arts   Ideas

You are receiving this message because you signed up
for email newsletters from The New York Review.

Update your address or preferences

View this newsletter online

The New York Review of Books
207 East 32nd Street, New York, NY 10016-6305

Categories: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply