Uncategorized

The Triumphs and Travails of American Marxism

WEB VERSION
October 20, 2025

To Free Labor

As a young man, Karl Marx had once contemplated moving to the United States and had even gone so far as to apply for permission to emigrate to Texas. He was never to make the trip across the North Atlantic, but his ideas did. Starting in the 1850s, several of his treatises were first published in New York, including the “Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte,” and for years he made a living as a correspondent for The New York Tribune, where he, and sometimes his frequent co-author Friedrich Engels, wrote nearly 500 articles. By the end of the 19th century, Marx may not have necessarily become a household name, but his politics had spread near and far, from the Lower East Side to Harlem, to Alabama, Texas, and California. Reviewing Andrew Hartman’s Karl Marx in America, Robin Blackburn argues that Marx’s influence on American politics crops up in surprising places: His ideas influenced labor activists and progressives at the turn of the 20th century, inspired political parties and bohemian intellectuals, and even helped spur on social movements. Blackburn finds that Hartman, in offering “a kaleidoscopic vision of Marxism in the United States in the 19th, 20th, and 21st centuries,” demonstrates how Marx, even if he never made it to the United States, has cast a considerable shadow on both the American past and present. Even today, Blackburn concludes, there remains “the question of where American Marxism fits” into US politics. Read “The Triumphs and Travails of 
American Marxism”

ADVERTISEMENT

A Family Business

Ever since Donald Trump’s election in 2016, liberals and radicals alike have struggled to understand the meaning of his rise and the persistence of his politics. Answers have abounded, but few have traced his appeal, or his understanding of politics and the economy, to the seismic changes in American capitalism that took place in the 1970s and ’80s. As large publicly traded corporations, built around elaborate bureaucracies and beholden to shareholders, began to be replaced by a proliferation of privately held family firms and holding companies, a shift took place in American politics and culture—from following the decisions of public boards and groups to bending to the whims of single individuals often beholden to no one and operating outside public scrutiny. This system of private-firm capitalism, Melinda Cooper argues in her book Counterrevolution: Extravagance and Austerity in Public Finance, helped launch Trump’s career and explains his continued appeal. Writing about Cooper’s book, Kim Phillips-Fein argues that this shift in America’s ownership structure did something else too: It offered Trump a theory of politics, an understanding of how to run a state in which decision-making operated much as it did within the realm of private companies and firms with which he was most familiar: “Trump’s autocratic style is not just a quirk of his personality,” Phillips-Fein writes; “it’s emblematic of the type of businessman he is”—and equally of the type of capitalist economy from which he emerged. Read “How the Capitalism of the 1980s Created Donald Trump’s Theory of the State”

ADVERTISEMENT
Walter Lippmann’s Lost Publics
Arguably no American journalist wielded as much influence as Walter Lippmann did in the 20th century. But what did he do with that power?
Gerald Howard
The Sonic Risks of PUP and Rico Nasty
On their new albums, the punk rockers and rapper break all the rules.
Bijan Stephen
The Blood Diamonds of Brazil
When an Amazonian tribe tried to regulate the mines on their territory, they invited the violence of modern life into their homeland.
Jimin Kang
“To Free Someone Else”: Toni Morrison the Book Editor
A recent book on her career in publishing makes the case that the great American novelist should also be seen as a pathbreaking editor.
Marina Magloire
Support The Nation’s Journalism
At a time when our republic is threatened like never before by oligarchy and unchecked power, support progressive, independent journalism that holds the powerful to account and fights for justice.
Donate Today
Not yet a subscriber of The Nation?
Get one year of unlimited digital access for just $15.
Subscribe
You are subscribed to Books & the Arts. Want to change how you receive these e-mails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe.
Privacy PolicyAdvertiseContact Us
© 2025 The Nation
520 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018

Categories: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply