This week, I finished watching Season 2 of the Apple TV show Severance. It’s a difficult show to explain without spoilers, or if you haven’t perused the works of Karl Marx or Immanuel Kant recently. It’s generally a show about the alienation of labor, in a sci-fi, psychological horror kind of way.
I enjoyed Season 1 of the show, but it was incredibly white-coded. There were Black speaking characters, and an Asian one, but their race meant nothing. In the show’s version of dystopian corporate shenanigans, “racism” was apparently the only societal ill that had been completely solved. Bully for them.
Season 2 hits differently. One of the main characters in the show is named Seth Milchick, and my editor informs me that “milchick” not only sounds Jewish but can be read (and has been read by some Severance obsessives) as a play on the Yiddish word milchig, or dairy, in the kosher food system—a system, she notes, that is all about keeping things separate. Her theory is that this wordplay is deliberate, a comment not only about race but also on the character’s role as both an enforcer of severance and a victim of it. (For those wondering, yes, my editor and I text television show fan theories to each other while chronicling the end of democracy.)
I have a slightly different take (about the show). I have no problem believing that on paper, Milchick’s character was written as a Jewish man. But in the show, he’s played by actor Tramell Tillman, who happens to be Black. I also have no problem believing that Tillman walked into that audition, blew everyone away, and was cast in his role, racial intentions be damned.
Milchick is Black but isn’t played as a self-aware Black man in Season 1. He’s just a middle-manager, an overseer really, charged with keeping the workers on task and in the dark. However, in Season 2, the show starts to play with the stress and difficulty of being a Black man in a white company—one that is run more like a cult. There is an awesome scene where Milchick is “gifted” with portraits of the company-cult’s all-white founders, but the founders’ pictures have been painted Black to make him feel “included.” They gave this man essentially some portraits in Blackface, and expected to be happy about it, and Tillman conveys the offense and insult of the whole thing, while saying “thank you,” and smiling at the Candace Owens–like Black woman who excitedly gave him the portraits.
Later in the season, Milchick is reprimanded by his white superiors for being too well-spoken. They don’t like that he uses “big words.” When he finally pushes back, he tells his boss to “devour feculence.” I cheered at my television. For a more in-depth analysis of Milchick, check out this post on Contraband Camp.
Through it all, however, Milchick is still a company man, still an overseer, still a bad guy on the show. He makes decisions I would never make, in a situation I would never find myself in, and yet I found myself relating to his character. This white-ass show has tapped into the subtle forms of racial oppression and insult that take place all across corporate America, and I believe any Black person who has ever worked for “the Man” would find Milchick’s character instantly recognizable. It’s a testament to Tillman’s acting, for sure, but also shows a deft hand by the show’s creator (Dan Erickson), director (Ben Stiller), and other assorted showrunners to essentially Blackify a Jewish-ish-coded character in a way that doesn’t make me immediately recoil. Last time I saw a white team write a Black character with this level of depth and complexity, I was watching David Simon’s The Wire.
If you were, like me, inclined to give Severance a pass because you’re not particularly interested in white people’s dystopian fantasy problems, give it another look. And “hang in there” until Season 2.