If you are a reader of political news, then you are familiar with what has become a tired genre: the earnest op-ed arguing that voters of conscience need to remain outraged at Donald Trump’s inescapable presence in American life and steadfast in opposing his return to the White House. Yet as these well-meaning editorials mount, they have started to reek a little of wishful thinking, masking the sour realization, evident in all the polls, that the anti-Trump energy that fueled Joe Biden’s election in 2020 is spent. In a sweeping survey of the challenges Democrats face in the 2024 election, New York‘s Jonathan Chait explains how the anti-Trump coalition fell apart, urging Democratic leaders and voters alike to squarely face the unthinkable: that this specific coalition isn’t coming back together anytime soon.