Economics/Class Relations

The Boomerang CEO dilemma

April 22, 2023

 

A NOTE FROM OUR EDITOR-IN-CHIEF ALYSON SHONTELL

When companies are in crisis, they may look to their past chief executives to help them through the storm. These boomerang CEOs are often iconic figures for the business—think Disney’s Bob Iger. But when boards go reaching into the past, hoping to leverage old leadership, it could be a sign they haven’t been successful at succession planning, as Fortune‘s Paige McGlauflin writes in her recent piece:
In times of distress, boomerang CEOs are a handy pick for boards and typically require considerably less training than a new CEO.

 

But the second—or third—CEO tour is indicative of managerial dysfunction and poor succession planning, leadership experts say. Worse still, the data shows boomerangs aren’t always more effective than first-time corner office holders. According to a study of 167 returning CEOs from the S&P Composite 1500 between 1992 and 2017, their annual stock performance was 10.1% lower than that of their first-time counterparts. That’s a searing indictment.

 

Additionally, boomerang CEOs may not recognize the company they’re returning to in today’s fast-paced business environment and lack the skills to address new challenges. Over the last three years, CEOs have grappled with a global pandemic, social justice protests, supply chain chaos—the list goes on.

 

But when push comes to shove, and there’s no better option, ex-CEOs are a sensical choice as long as their reinstatement is temporary. A better option? Prioritize succession planning well before the current CEO’s departure.

Read her entire story below.

 

A corporate hero or a tragedy? Why boomerang CEOs like Bob Iger and Sergio Ermotti may actually signal a leadership failing
BY PAIGE MCGLAUFLIN

 

APRIL 17, 2023

 
Fortune’s top trending stories:

MAGAZINE

— Preventing burnout is now the number one job for bosses. These 7 strategies can protect your teams

HOUSING

— Homebuyers are saving thousands by talking their way into mortgage rate buydowns. Here’s how to do it

— Things are getting really weird in the housing market

FINANCE

— How a pod of SVB bankers are starting over at a new firm after their world fell apart

PERSONAL FINANCE

— Childcare is so expensive that families are spending a quarter of their income on it

— Are we in a recession? What it really means—and how to prepare

CRYPTO

— Taylor Swift avoided $100 million FTX debacle by questioning whether the exchange was selling unregistered securities

A.I.

— Snap’s ‘My AI’ chatbot tells users it doesn’t know their location. It does.

— Google CEO Sundar Pichai says ‘hallucination problems’ still plague A.I. tech and he doesn’t know why

— A.I. was supposed to improve decision making. Instead, business leaders are so overwhelmed with data they’re struggling to function

SUCCESS

— Workers aren’t scared of a recession—they’re still looking for a new job

— Companies that ditch degree requirements in favor of skills-based hiring could see an explosion of talent with 19x the workers

 

 

Creators of new sci-fi series Mrs. Davis talk religion vs. A.I.
Alludo’s CEO on Fortune‘s Leadership Next podcast
 

 
The global learning community for next-generation executives.
Unlock your full potential with Fortune Connect

Fortune Connect is where the leaders of tomorrow become the change-makers of today. Accelerate your career, expand your network, and make a positive impact difference in the world.

 

Learn more

 
 

 

Learn how artificial intelligence and machine learning are shaping the future of business with the weekly Eye on A.I. newsletter. 

Leave a Reply