On the other hand, I think sports leagues should be voluntary communities that are capable of deciding their own standards. I saw an article recently about a (biological) female football player at some university or other. I tend to be of the view of “whoever gets the job done.” From what I understand (maybe I’m wrong), the objection to having transwomen in women’s sports is that it is physically dangerous and unfair competition-wise because transwomen still have male levels of strength.
These kinds of controversies are the natural consequence of having the state involved in every aspect of society, particularly one as large and diverse as ours. Every issue becomes a political issue so of course, every group wants to be sure their interests are represented. I played Little League baseball in rural Virginia in the 1970s. In the midst of our redneck, fundamentalist townships, we had black and white kids, boys and girls, some gay kids (in retrospect), and even a hemophiliac kid all on the same teams, with one of the team sponsors being a cross-dressing biological woman gas station owner who presented as male, and no one seemed to have a problem with each other.
By William Jennings, USA Today
Outgoing Democratic Rep. Tulsi Gabbard is facing backlash after she joined Republican Rep. Markwayne Mullin to introduce legislation specifying that Title IX protections for female athletes are based on “biological sex.”
The text of the bill introduced Thursday calls for Title IX compliance to be “determined on the basis of biological sex as determined at birth by a physician.” Title IX, which forbids sex-based discrimination in any school receiving federal funds, is best known for ensuring that women’s college sports programs receive equal support – and a federal judge recently applied it to rule a transgender woman could not be kept off a women’s sports team.