Police State/Civil Liberties

Former DHS and Defense Dept Spokesperson: Trump’s Response to Civil Unrest in Portland is Damaging to Our Government and Our Democracy

Trump is only able to deploy DHS forces to cities because the military-intelligence services (“deep state”) are allowing him to do so. The question is what is their angle? Are they delibertately allowing Trump to trip up and fall?

By David Lapan

Just Security

I believe deeply that how our government’s security forces are seen by the American public is critical to their ability to protect us and our ability to maintain a healthy democracy. That belief comes from experience: I served for decades in the U.S. Marine Corps, as a Department of Defense spokesperson, and as the Trump administration’s first Department of Homeland of Security spokesperson. It’s as an American who cares profoundly about the missions of both DOD and DHS—and believes their reputations are essential to achieving those missions—that I’ve followed the Trump administration’s heavy-handed response to protests across the country in recent months, and especially DHS’s role in that response. And I’m appalled by what I’m seeing. It’s damaging to DHS, and it’s damaging to American democracy.

Last month, the sight of U.S. military forces on the streets of our nation’s capital surprised and angered many Americans, including military and veteran communities, former diplomats, former senior national security leaders, and the general public. While federal, state, and local law enforcement officers were actively involved in the response to protests in Washington, D.C., it was the mixing of men and women in military uniforms and equipment as part of the law enforcement response that sparked particular concern for me. Images of military and military-looking individuals threatening the use of force, and in some instances actually using it, raised crucial questions about the appropriateness of a militarized response to civil unrest.

During the protests in D.C., the military units deployed in and around the city were a mix of National Guard and active duty forces. They wore their normal camouflage uniforms. Some were armed, some were unarmed. Although the active duty units were not called into action, the deployment of a rapid response force from the Army’s 82nd Airborne Division raised serious questions about the nature of the military’s response. National Guard units from the District and several states were deployed on the streets of Washington for several days. Some were involved in the controversial clearing of Lafayette Park for the president’s photo op at a church; and low-flying National Guard helicopters were used as crowd control measures. These actions sparked widespread condemnation and led the Secretary of Defense to order a formal investigation as well as Congress to hold oversight hearings.


1 reply »

  1. “Trump’s Response to Civil Unrest in Portland is Damaging to Our Government and Our Democracy”

    Wouldn’t it be much more accurate to say:

    “Local government’s LACK OF response to Civil Unrest in Portland is Damaging to Our Government and Our Democracy” ????

    The original George Floyd protestors had plenty to object to. But after the 8+ minutes of that outrage, what they had to object to was the incompetent reaction of the liberal, even left-wing government of Minneapolis, and their failure to prosecute the cops who killed George Floyd. The big protests DIDN’T start immediately: The failure of the government to prosecute the cops took days to cause the public to be enraged.

    Yes, there were other incidents, both before and after Floyd’s death. But generally, all or most of them didn’t make the Federal government the guilty party.

    I’m NOT one to defend the Federal Government!!! But we have crowds of stupid rioters who pretend that what they ought to be rioting, at least immediately, is the Feds. And then we have articles like this that mis-locate the blame. That is NOT productive!

    I’d be happy to protest the Federal government WHEN and for WHAT PURPOSE it makes sense. Right now, the rioters are just being stupid, and their defenders are being equally nuts.

Leave a Reply