Site icon Attack the System

Feted or forgotten? A tale of two very different anarchists

[Plus audio version]

An important split took place in the French anarchist movement at the very end of the nineteenth century.

This revolved around the question of whether the conviction of Jewish army captain Alfred Dreyfus for treason represented an important question of injustice and institutional anti-semitism or whether, au contraire, the case was irrelevant to the anarchist struggle.

François Jarrige writes in the latest issue of Brasero: revue de contre-histoire: “The Dreyfus affair, which tore France apart from 1897-1898 onwards, also divided the anarchist milieu”. [1]

In what he terms “an extreme polarisation”, anarchists, “traditionally distrustful of the army and the state, split into convinced dreyfusards and supporters of a strict indifference to what they considered an internal conflict within bourgeois institutions.

“Sébastien Faure, a major figure in the anarchist movement and co-founder of Le Libertaire, nevertheless managed to drag a number of activists into the active defence of Dreyfus”. [2]

We’ll come back to Faure later, but first I want to relate what Jarrige has to say about one of the anarchists who refused to climb on board the dreyfusard bandwagon – Emile Gravelle (1855-1920).

He was the founder of a current in the French anarchist movement called naturien – there is no real English equivalent but the meaning is nature-loving or nature-based.

This, Jarrige explains, emerged in the Parisian quartier of Montmartre and was a current that was “critical of industrial society and its goods, idealising prehistorical and primitive living and calling for a return to nature”. [3]

Gravelle, an anarchist painter, illustrator, pamphleteer and activist, was one of the first to formulate such a critique of “progress” and “civilisation”, prefiguring the green anarchism that emerged towards the end of the twentieth century. [4]

An important influence on Gravelle’s understanding of the world was his five-year stay in Buenos Aires, after leaving his home town of Douai in northern France at the age of 30.

Jarrige writes: “At the time Argentina was going through a phase of expansion: political stabilisation after civil wars, the conquest of indigenous lands, the expansion of cattle-rearing on the great plains of the pampa and a massive influx of European immigrants. This context of brutal modernisation, mixing prosperity and social violence, had a deep impact on Gravelle…

“When he returned to France in 1890 he brought out a pamphlet in which he related his unpleasant experience. In this virulent text, La République argentine dénoncée (‘The Argentine Republic denounced’), he describes how he had been taken in by the embroidered tales of a ‘shipping agent in the rue de Dunkerque‘, only to discover a reality of misery, exploitation and disillusionment.

“He writes about the diseases, the violence of the gauchos, the insalubrity of the towns and the suffering of immigrants pushed into suicide or madness. This pamphlet, laced with bitterness, also bears witness to a political realization: Gravelle denounces the illusions of progress and the mechanisms of capitalist exploitation”. [5]

Gravelle’s years in South America shaped his understanding of modernity in another way. Through his encounters with indigenous Guarani people he discovered “man, in the midst of nature, happy as a god in the triumphant splendour of its strength and beauty”. [6]

Jarrige says this provided him with “an alternative model to the European ways of living shaped by industry, the growing consumerism and imperialism”. [7]

It fed his rejection of modern urbanisation and his aspiration to a way of life founded on simplicity, autonomy and closeness to nature – “when Gravelle returned to Paris, he was thus no longer simply an illustrator looking for work: he was the bearer of a vision of the world opposed to that of the European civilisation of his age”. [8]

In the early 1890s Gravelle set up home in Montmartre, a bohemian, artistic and anarchic enclave on a hill in Paris. At the time, it was still semi-rural and was imbibed with the spirit of resistance to the new urban order, inherited from the Paris Commune of 1871.

Says Jarrige: “This landscape in transition, where the industrial smoke of the capital mixed with the last remains of rurality, deeply nourished Gravelle’s anarchist imagination”. [9]

“The rapid transformation of the quartier under the impact of urbanisation and property speculation reinforced in Gravelle’s mind the idea that modern civilisation destroys the natural conditions of human life. His drawings often show black plumes of factory smoke, collapsed quarries or silhouettes of old windmills.

“La Butte [The Hill] became for him a laboratory where he could observe the advance of industrial modernity, but also a place for imagining alternatives. It symbolised a communalist tradition of protecting natural and public spaces threatened by power”. [10]

In 1894 Gravelle founded a four-page journal called L’Etat naturel (‘The natural state’), which ran for four issues until 1898. Jarrige explains that this periodical, largely written and illustrated by Gravelle himself, was at the heart of naturienisme, contrasting natural human life with the misery of factory workers, the ugliness of the city and the artificiality of “civilisation”. [11]

When Gravelle started a naturien group in Montmartre in 1895 it was joined by penniless artists, singers and people who worked on the railways, in a bank or as a cobbler or barrel-maker.

Comments Jarrige: “This very mixed group testifies to the attractiveness of the idea of returning to nature among individuals facing material precarity, the rapid upheavals of urban society and political disillusionment”. [12]

“The naturiens organised conferences, talks and even banquets which sometimes attracted nearly a hundred people. Their influence rapidly spread beyond Montmartre: groups appeared at the Bastille, in the Latin Quarter and then outside the capital, notably in Toulon and Bordeaux.

“Although they were few in number – with undoubtedly never more than a hundred or so members – the movement built itself around intense publishing activity”. [13]

Journals such as Le Bulletin des Harmoniens (‘The Bulletin of the Harmonians’), La Debâcle sociale (‘The Social Disaster’), L’Idée libre (‘The Free Idea’), La Nouvelle Humanité (‘The New Humanity’) and Le Naturien flourished at this time.

Jarrige tells us: “The first of the four issues of the journal Le Naturien was, moreover, distributed beyond Paris, in Bordeaux, Dijon, Le Havre, Limoges, Marseilles, Montpellier, Roubaix, Saint-Nazaire, Toulon and Tours”. [14]

In its final issue, in 1898, Gravelle questioned the relevance of the insurrections and revolutions usually favoured by anarchists and the “left”.

He insisted: “You could perpetually behead kings, depose emperors and disembowel presidents of the Republic, but the situation will remain the same as long as there are mines, factories and building sites.

“As long as the artificiality that has been established over the centuries is considered as the base of our system of living, there will be exploitation of man by man, there will be despoilment and the ongoing and aggrevated degradation of nature…

“To those who talk of revolution while still wanting to hold on to superfluous Artifice, we say this: you are conserving elements of servitude, you will therefore always be slaves; you think you can seize control of material production to appropriate it for yourselves, but, in reality, this material production which constitutes the strength of your oppressors is quite safe from your covetous regard”. [15]

Gravelle concluded that as long as this industrial system of production existed, the people would never know freedom. “Material Progress is the fruit of slavery”, he insisted. [16]

Jarrige says that this viewpoint, so starkly in contrast with the industrialist Marxist outlook, had a considerable influence on the French anarchist scene, until Gravelle became marginalised around 1898.

In April of that year his girlfriend, said to have been “a fervent naturienne since the beginning” died in hospital for now-unknown reasons and Gravelle was left in a state of shocked grief. [17]

At the same time, as we have heard, the Dreyfus affair dominated the political scene and by refusing to get involved, Gravelle was cut off from many other anarchists, although he was still involved in the movement until his death in 1920.

He seems to have particularly fallen out of favour because of supposedly “anti-semitic” illustrations, such as that of a French farmer disposing of a human-like vegetable labelled “Rothschild”. [18]

Jarrige does not challenge the “anti-semitic” label, but I would question whether drawing a humorous caricature of a well-known Jewish banker is “anti-semitic” per se – the figure is certainly not meant to represent Jews as a whole, or even all Jewish bankers, because the name “Rothschild” is specifically written on the forehead.

Is it not more likely that the target of Gravelle’s anger was the Rothschilds in particular – not “because they were Jewish” but because he knew full well that they were enemies of the people [19] and bore much responsibility for the industrial-imperial misery and slavery he had been witnessing and denouncing both in France and Argentina?

Going back to the split in the French anarchist movement, the leading dreyfusard Sébastien Faure (1858-1942) is the subject of another article in the same issue of Brasero.

There Anne Steiner explains that he founded the weekly journal Le Libertaire in 1895 and then the daily newspaper Le Journal du Peuple which led the anarchist charge in defence of Dreyfus and against anti-semtitism.

He is also rememberd for founding La Ruche (‘The Hive’), an experimental “alternative” boarding school which housed forty-odd girls and boys between the ages of six and 16.

Paying due credit to the Archives anarchistes website, [20] she digs deeper into Faure’s character with reference to the judicial files, released in 2018, which can be consulted there. [21]

In brief, Faure was a disgusting paedocriminal. The records show that in 1903 he was seen approaching three girls aged eight to 12 years old, offering them a few coins for sexual favours; in 1904 he was seen kissing a 12-year-old girl on the mouth; in 1907 he was found in the company of a woman suspected of prostituting her 14-year-old daughter and so on and so forth. [22]

Having been caught molesting little girls in the street in 1917 he fled Paris – taking with him funds from his journal and printing press – but was captured in Marseilles, found guilty and sentenced to six months in jail. At this point it transpired that he had, of course, also been abusing the children at his school La Ruche. [23]

A scandal also soon erupted over his links to disgraced politician Louis Malvy, whose Ministry of the Interior had, during his 1914-1917 term in office, paid subsidies to Faure’s La Ruche even though it had no legal status. [24]

Denying suggestions that Faure had been let off the hook for his child abuse for so long because of his links to the state, the former prefect of the Paris police, Emile Laurent, said that this was not how it had worked.

Faure’s constant paedocriminal activities could not have been proven in court, he insisted, but they allowed the police to exert a certain pressure on the anarchist, such as by ordering him to moderate the terms of his written and oral political statements. [25]

Steiner writes: “All the activists thus learned at this point that Sébastien Faure (pictured), child abuser and client of barely pubescent prostitutes, was controlled by the prefect of the police, who was perfectly well aware of his criminal activity. This evoked, even beyond the anarchist movement, a certain malaise and much questioning”. [26]

But Faure, remarkably, protested his innocence and claimed that he had been framed in a complicated and politically motivated state operation.

Others leapt to his defence and in 1919 backed up his story in a booklet called Une infamie. L’affaire Sébastien Faure (‘Scandal: The Sébastien Faure affair’).

Says Steiner: “This plea in favour of the old anarchist activist managed to quieten the doubts of those who had been troubled by his conviction and even more so by the evidence at his trial which depicted him as a very unsavoury individual. Until less than than two years later, there was a new affair”. [27]

In 1921 Faure and two other men in their early sixties were caught dragging two little girls, aged 11 and 12, into a flat in Paris, where they sexually abused them for four hours. Other victims were discovered and he was jailed for eight months. [28]

One might have thought that this would have led the French anarchist movement to finally denounce Faure and expel him from their midst.

But no – after his arrest Le Libertaire and the L’Union anarchiste published a communiqué in L’Humanité calling on the whole working class to show solidarity with this “upright and impeccable activist”. [29]

And when he had been jailed, Le Libertaire of June 17 1921 deplored his conviction for what they termed an “insignificant weakness” and hailed him as “the courageous friend of the working class”. [30]

Their version was again that he was the victim of a police set-up to discredit “the best revolutionary propagandist in the country”. Ignoring his long record of child abuse, they claimed a young girl had been cunningly placed in his path to frame him. [31]

While Faure denied child abuse, he rather gave the game away by dismissing anarchists who disapproved of such behaviour as “bourgeois”. [32]

Steiner relates how the paedocriminal was welcomed back into the anarchist fold after coming out of jail again and in 1925 was able to launch his L’Encyclopedie anarchiste project with a hundred collaborators who did not seem bothered about his character.

She adds, clearly somewhat outraged, that the “neo-malthusian activist” Jeanne Humbert (pictured below) completely misrepresented the facts about Faure in the 1949 biography she wrote about him.

For instance, she depicted the 1917 offence as having involved him touching and rubbing himself against women in the street, when it was really ten-year-old girls.

“Regarding the 1921 conviction, it’s even worse, as she describes the abused little girls as ‘debauched minors’, children of a ‘precocious vicefulness’”. Humbert also insisted that Faure did nothing to shock anyone not “blinded” by conventional morality. [33]

I was interested, surprised even, to see that the profile of Faure on French Wikipedia mentions that accusations of his paedocriminality were confirmed by the judicial archives made public eight years ago – and that it points readers to the Archives anarchistes site. [34]

It adds that he was a Freemason. “Sébastien Faure was initiated on June 28 1884 at the Vérité du Grand Orient de France lodge at Bordeaux… On November 3 1905, he joined the Le Progrès lodge in Paris. He resigned from Freemasonry on December 20 1917 after 33 years of involvement”. [35]

So there we have it.

Sébastien Faure, the police-controlled freemasonic paedophile who diverted anarchist energy into a struggle against “anti-semitism”, is still revered by the movement today.

Emile Gravelle, the anti-imperialist, anti-industrialist and nature-defending artist and campaigner who dared to poke fun at the industrial-imperialist Rothschilds, is today an obscure and half-forgotten figure.

It really is about time that real anarchists [36] got to their feet and made their presence known!

Real Anarchists
Upholding the true tradition
By Paul Cudenec

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Exit mobile version