Site icon Attack the System

Debunking Red King’s Defence of the Internet as The Playground

I just read an article by Red King which is profoundly wrong-headed. In it, he likens the internet to the rough and tumble of the playground and posits that there is, essentially, no difference between social media and real life. He argues that just like the life lessons one learns in the playground, one can take similar things from the rough and tumble of social media. This article seeks to refute that one.

 

First, I should remind people that I have in the past defended the life lessons of the playground, including its darkest aspects such as bullying. Citing David Foster Wallace’s essay ‘Authority and American Usage’ I suggested that bullying in school serves a key social function in teaching kids how to navigate different social situations and to switch idioms. Namely, the way you interface with the teachers is and should be different from the way you interface with your classmates. This stance of mine led to bitterness on the part of some people who just could not handle this argument. I suggested that it is never the bullied who learns, for them life in school can be miserable, it is, rather, the bystanders who learn. To quote Wallace directly:

When his peers are ostracizing the SNOOTlet or giving him monstrous quadruple Wedgies or holding him down and taking turns spitting on him, there’s serious learning going on. Everybody here is learning except the little SNOOT – in fact, what the SNOOTlet is being punished for is precisely his failure to learn.

All this happens naturally and organically in every class and year group in every school. At least it did when I was a kid, who knows about now.

 

I even suggested, citing the tragic case of a doctor called James who appeared on the The Island with Bear Grylls, that people typically reproduce the relations they learn in the schoolyard in later life. In his appearance on The Island, James proved to be so unpopular with his fellow contestants that they voted him off the island – even though the show did not have such a voting mechanism! Grylls in his voiceover suggested that had this been real life and not a TV show, the inhabitants of the island likely would have killed him. The show ended with James sitting alone on a log crying. He said something along the lines of ‘I thought this could be a new start for me … all my life, I thought it was other people, but it was me, it was me all along.’ Dark stuff, but also devastatingly true. Therefore, like Red King, you might say I am broadly pro-schoolground dynamics.

 

The trouble is, however, that social media is not anything like the playground. The first and most obvious fact is that – at least in my school days – if you were a boy, the prospect of physical violence was always around the corner. On social media, you are separated by distance. Thus people say things to each other they wouldn’t dream of saying in real life, because they’d likely receive a punch. The ‘rough and tumble’ simply comes in the form of insults and words. Ultimately, internet fisticuffs is not only a waste of time, but also somewhat feminine, and I say that as someone who can scrap with the best of them. The insurmountable problem for Red King’s analogy is that people are typically hiding behind keyboards. In the school, there aren’t really many hiding places, since everyone must be seen, in the flesh as they really are. On the internet, people could be shut-in jobs, paid shills, CIA agents, and most, if not all of them, will be complete strangers. In other words, we have moved from a situation on a human scale to a situation of mass and scale subject to manipulation.

Captive Dreamer in school.

Red King has not internalised, or appears not to have internalised, what I said 672 days ago: that the online right is entirely fake. Thus you aren’t dealing with the natural and organic hierarchies that emerge in school, but with altogether manufactured ones subject to mass botting and so on. The mechanics to signal position are distorted by clandestine and malign interests in a way that simply would not happen in the playground. It is fundamentally polluted in such a way that, at least in the cases of Facebook, Twitter X, and even the ‘Notes’ section of Substack, the only way to ensure digital hygiene is remove yourself from the pollution.

 

Red King suggests the de facto libertarian course of relying on personal discernment for this, but the brutal fact is, most people do not have the ability or time to exercise such discernment. I am not specifically picking on Dave Greene here, but this is a decent example of what I mean:

Who is John Carter? How can he be trusted? Why is he quoting the abject and pathetic Tory Boy outfit Pimlico Journal which is frequently astroturfed and boosted in the corporate press? Now Dave has promoted both Carter and Pimlico Journal to his timeline and his audience. Here, indirectly, Greene acted as the thin edge of the Pimlico wedge. Whose interests does Pimlico serve? If you can’t answer that question, you probably shouldn’t be thoughtlessly promoting them.

 

This is just one tiny and somewhat inconsequential example of the total lack of discernment and digital hygiene across the entire space. I have made countless such mistakes in the past accidentally promoting bad actors simply by dint of the fact that I was on X and swam in polluted waters. The ‘playground’ Red King describes chiefly consists of this random and careless boosting of questionable actors magnified by many times. Most people do not really care about who and why they are boosting ‘based things’ because the internet is not real. It is closer to being a pastime (at best) or surrogate activity (at worst). People simply cannot and will not treat their social media associations with the same discernment and seriousness that any real life situation would require. Hence, the space is simply drenched in pollution and dominated by bad actors. Given these facts, there are no genuine real playground dynamics.

 

In a real playground, Captive Dreamer would have had his head shoved down the toilet, and not have 85,000 followers and artificially botted likes on X. In fact, many of the ‘social media stars’ in the supposed playground that Red King has (baffingly) chosen to defend are the ‘library crew’ that he laments. This is why the space is filled with maladjusted, socially repulsive spergs and spiteful mutants. The exact same qualities that make politicial organisation with such people impossible are custom-made to propel them to micro-superstardom on Elon Musk’s hellsite.

 

Red King suggests that the problem is ‘me’ rather than the whole rotten edifice. He appears to see these platforms as neutral ‘play spaces’ rather than for what they actually are: informational weapons of the security state and direct methods of mass perception management. I advocate a total unplugging from the worst of them such as X, and a purging of your timelines of most forms of algorithmic slop. The many people who have done this have remarked on what wonders it has done for their mood, their mental wellbeing, and their awareness and presence in the world. That doesn’t sound like a ‘me’ problem, it sounds like a problem with social media itself. I don’t know if this article from Red King was a form of personal bargaining from him as he sees more of his friends following the correct, just and righteous path of withdrawing from polluted waters; perhaps he is justifying to himself why he won’t leave X. Perhaps he did not fully think through what he was saying. Whatever the case, ‘it’s probably a you issue mate.’


Subscribe to The Forbidden Texts

By Neema Parvini · Hundreds of paid subscribers
Learning how to Ride the Tiger in a mixed-up, muddled-up, shook-up world.
Exit mobile version