How famous people use the language of democracy to demand agreement and turn dissent into a character flaw.
During Brazil’s 2022 presidential campaign, Anitta, a Brazilian pop and funk singer from Rio de Janeiro, offered to help promote Lula online. Gusttavo Lima, a Brazilian singer from Minas Gerais, publicly backed Jair Bolsonaro. Both could reach people who might never sit through a presidential debate. But what did either endorsement tell a voter about how the candidate would govern? [1, 2]
I’m happy to hear why a singer, an actor or a footballer backs a candidate. They may have thought about the choice more carefully than I have. I’d like to hear the argument. A voter deciding whom to trust with a public hospital, a school or a bus network needs to know what the candidate plans to do and why anyone believes they can deliver it.
That applies equally when a singer pauses a concert to talk about a war, when an actor uses an awards speech to endorse a cause, or when an influencer tells followers that any decent person knows how to vote. A celebrity can start a conversation with people a politician might never reach. What happens when those people start asking questions?
When a concert becomes a rally
Bruce Springsteen, Bono, Tom Morello and Roger Waters are familiar examples of the overlap between music and politics. Their artistic achievements vary according to taste. Their right to express a political opinion is beyond dispute. So is the audience’s right to find the opinion ill-informed, self-important or simply tedious.
Springsteen and Bono have spent decades writing about subjects that are already political. Anyone buying a ticket can reasonably expect to hear something about the world outside the venue. I draw the line at the moment a performer starts treating a crowd as an assembly of people who have already agreed with him. A song can challenge an audience and leave people arguing about it on the way home. A sermon generally comes with the conclusion attached.
Roger Waters offers a more serious example. He has publicly defended Nicolás Maduro, including in an interview with Piers Morgan. Waters has plenty to say about Israel. I would like to hear him apply that same appetite for questioning power to a government he regards with sympathy. [3]
His former Pink Floyd bandmate David Gilmour has said he would refuse to share a stage with people who support autocratic dictators. After years of speculation about a reunion, that strikes me as a perfectly adequate answer. The disagreement concerns what each man is prepared to excuse. [4]
Then there is Tom Morello of Rage Against the Machine. In a 2018 interview with the Brazilian press, Morello acknowledged how little he knew about Brazilian politics while expressing a firm view on the case involving Lula. I wish more celebrities were capable of making the first admission. I also wish they would stop and consider what it ought to do to the certainty of the second statement. [5]
Hollywood goes campaigning
When actors endorse a candidate, the appeal often rests on a curious transfer of trust. We liked them in a film. We have watched their interviews for years. We may feel we know them. So when they tell us which candidate will protect democracy, defend working people or save the country, something of that familiarity travels with the claim.
Campaigns understand the value of that familiarity. Put a recognisable actor in a campaign video and it may reach people who would scroll straight past a speech by the candidate. The actor gets to support a cause they believe in. The campaign gets attention it might otherwise struggle to earn. The viewer still has to decide whether anyone has made a decent argument.
There is a difference between saying, “I’m voting for this person and here’s why,” and saying, “If you care about your country, you know how you have to vote.” The first gives me a reason I can consider. The second asks me to prove that I am a decent person by agreeing with someone I have never met.
Some celebrities reach for two accusations when they talk about the right. A candidate is a “threat to democracy,” and the people who vote for him are “racists.” At that point I want to hear specifics. Which proposal would undermine an election, weaken the courts or restrict political opposition? Which statement or policy is racist, and who would it affect? Those are serious charges. Give me something I can examine.
It gets uglier when the accusation moves from the politician to everyone who voted for him. In Brazil, two people can vote for the same candidate for entirely different reasons. One may care most about public security. The other may be worried about keeping a small business open. Ask them why they voted that way and you might hear something you hadn’t considered. Call them racists before they’ve answered and you’ve given them every reason to stop talking.
And if I expect a celebrity to back up an accusation against someone on the right, I owe people the same courtesy when I accuse someone on the left. I can’t demand an argument from them and then expect my own labels to do the work.
When Brazilian celebrities take sides
Anitta and Gusttavo Lima were part of a much wider split during Brazil’s 2022 election. Actress Bruna Marquezine backed Lula, as did musicians Caetano Veloso and Chico Buarque. Caetano helped lead a push for voters to rally behind Lula in the first round, and Chico appeared at campaign events. On Bolsonaro’s side were actress Regina Duarte, who had served as his secretary of culture, actor Malvino Salvador and footballer Neymar. [1, 2, 6, 7]
Telling people how you intend to vote and actively campaigning for their votes are both legitimate. Once you ask for someone’s vote, though, you should expect them to ask what the candidate will do with it. Here in Brasília, I’d like to hear what an endorsement means for the person who spends two hours on buses every day or who is trying to keep a small business afloat. What policy are you asking them to support? What makes you think it will work?
I find the fans’ reaction just as revealing. When an artist endorses the candidate we already support, we praise them for speaking out. When another artist endorses the opponent, suddenly we want celebrities to stick to their day jobs. If I’m going to question Gusttavo Lima’s case for Bolsonaro, I ought to be just as willing to question Anitta’s case for Lula. And if either one gives me a good reason, I ought to be willing to hear it.
The echo chamber has a famous face
A celebrity endorses a candidate. I watch the clip, read the comments and send it to a friend. By the time I next open the app, I may see another clip making the same argument, a reaction video praising it and an influencer ridiculing anyone who disagrees. After a while, it feels as though everybody has reached the same conclusion. My neighbour can open the same app and come away convinced of the opposite.
Social media can narrow a discussion without anyone having to delete a single comment. The way platforms rank posts shapes which arguments I see first, which ones I see repeatedly and which ones I have to go looking for. An angry reply can keep me watching just as effectively as a post I agree with. And when an opposing view does reach me, it may come in the form of a ten-second clip selected by someone who already thinks it’s ridiculous. I see the worst version of their argument and the best-rehearsed version of my own.
Celebrities amplify this because their opinions travel well beyond their own followers. An actor’s endorsement becomes an entertainment headline, then a reaction video, then a screenshot in a WhatsApp group. Each time it travels, there’s a chance the reasoning gets shorter and the famous face stays. Soon the argument is about whether we admire the actor, whether we would still watch their films and what it says about our friends if they agree with them. The candidate’s actual record can disappear from the conversation altogether.
Politicians can build audiences of their own. In Brazil, federal deputy André Janones withdrew from the 2022 presidential race to back Lula. Four years later, during Lula’s re-election campaign, Janones said his WhatsApp channel, Exército do Lula, had 3.3 million followers. That gave him a direct line to an audience larger than the population of many Brazilian cities. [8, 9]
Now imagine a message from a channel like that being forwarded into a Brazilian WhatsApp group full of friends. Someone asks what the candidate has actually promised to do. Within minutes, somebody asks how that friend could possibly be on the other side. He hasn’t even said how he plans to vote. He asked a question. The next person who had the same question reads the exchange and puts the phone down.
The person who sent the original message may never see that conversation. The people in the group will see one another again on Saturday. That gives their reaction a weight the original message never had.
The causes that come with applause
I support the Palestinians’ right to self-determination. I condemn the killing of civilians in Gaza, and I think Benjamin Netanyahu’s government deserves scrutiny. I also want to know where some of the loudest celebrity voices were when Hamas attacked Israel on 7 October 2023 and took people hostage. I have the same question for anyone who speaks movingly about Israeli victims and falls silent when the victims are Palestinian.
An actor who uses an awards speech to take a position on the war can expect the audience to ask what that position means. What future do you envisage for Palestinians? What future do you envisage for Israelis? If you’re calling for a cultural boycott, who exactly are you asking people to boycott, and what do you expect it to achieve?
The harder question is whether you’ll apply the same principles when the room stops applauding.
What celebrity influence can do well
In 1985, Steven Van Zandt brought together dozens of artists for Sun City, a campaign against South African apartheid. Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan, Bono and Miles Davis were among those who took part. The campaign identified an injustice and gave musicians a specific action they could take. They could refuse to perform at Sun City. [10]
Decades later, Van Zandt has used his TeachRock project to support Holocaust education. He has also challenged the comparison between boycotting Israel and the campaign against Sun City. People are free to dispute his reasoning. I would rather hear that argument than watch artists pressured to cancel appearances, institutions pushed to withdraw invitations and people treated as suspect for agreeing to share a room. [11]
Van Zandt’s career also complicates the idea that rock belongs to one political camp. I have heard people proclaim that rock is the music of rebellion and then, practically in the same breath, insist that everyone who plays it must follow the same political line. You would think a genre that made a living out of telling people to get stuffed could survive a disagreement.
Your vote is still yours
I am happy to hear a musician explain why he backs a candidate, an actor talk about a cause she has studied, or an athlete speak about something he has lived through. Each might know something I ought to hear. I want the freedom to ask follow-up questions, disagree with the answers and still enjoy the next album, film or match.
If an actor can explain what a candidate’s housing policy would do for renters, I’ll listen. If a singer can tell me why a government deserves defending and apply the same standards to its opponents, I’ll listen. And if either of them tells me that decent people all vote the same way, I’ll make up my own mind about the candidate and about the person delivering the lecture.
I can buy your records, admire your films and disagree with you in the voting booth. If that offends you, perhaps you misunderstood what I bought a ticket for.
References
- Folha de S.Paulo. Reporting on Caetano Veloso, Anitta and Gusttavo Lima during the 2022 presidential campaign. www1.folha.uol.com.br
- UOL Splash. Reporting on celebrity endorsements and campaign appearances during the 2022 runoff. www.uol.com.br
- Piers Morgan Uncensored. Interview with Roger Waters discussing Nicolás Maduro and Venezuela. Watch the interview
- The Guardian. Interview with David Gilmour on his career and the prospect of sharing a stage with Roger Waters again. theguardian.com
- GZH. Interview with Tom Morello on his 2018 Porto Alegre show and Brazilian politics. GZH
- Folha de S.Paulo. Coverage of celebrity endorsements and their potential influence on voters in 2022. www1.folha.uol.com.br
- GZH. Reporting on the actors, musicians and athletes who backed Lula or Bolsonaro in 2022. gauchazh.clicrbs.com.br
- Agência Brasil. Reporting on André Janones’s withdrawal from the 2022 presidential race and endorsement of Lula. agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br
- Agência Brasil. Reporting on Exército do Lula and Janones’s October 2026 follower count. agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br
- The Washington Post. Contemporary reporting on the 1985 Sun City anti-apartheid campaign. The Washington Post
- Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle. Reporting on Steven Van Zandt’s Holocaust education work and his views on cultural boycotts. The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle
